Quick Links

Wendy's Creative Collections & Coins, in Peoria, IL, is the area's leading coin shop serving Fulton, Tazewell, Knox, La Salle and Woodford counties and surrounding areas since 1999. We buy and sell locally, regionally and nationally which gives our customers access to broad markets and competitive pricing. Our prices for scrap gold and silver jewelry, precious metals, collector coins and paper money and vintage sports cards, memorabilia and collectibles are always competitive. Our selling prices are equally current and competitive. And Wendy's guarantees the authenticity of every thing we sell. Wendy's also has free appraisals, a large inventory and knowledgeable staff so you have winning combination for meeting all your needs in one place. For more information, visit Wendy's Creative Collections & Coins in Peoria.

Free Appraisals
Working with Banks, Attorneys and Estates
PCGS, NGC, NCS and PMG Authorized Dealer
Beginning in June 2019 Wendy's Will Be Closed on Tuesdays
Please Call to Confirm Saturday Hours Due to Shows and Out of Town Commitments

SPECIALTIES:

Buying Gold and Silver

Rare Coins and Currency

Sports Memorabilia

Associations:

ANA (American Numismatic Association)

Illinois Numismatic Association

PCGS, NGC, NCS and PMG Submission Dealer

Better Business Bureau

Products:

All US and Foreign Coins and Paper Money

US Mint Silver and Gold Eagle Coins

Proof and Mint Sets and Commemorative Issues Gold, Silver and Platinum Coins

Royal Canadian Mint Gold and Silver Canadian Maple Leaf Coins

.999 Silver Rounds & Bars

Sterling Silver Flatware

Hollowware and Coins

Scrap Gold Jewelry - 10k, 14k, 18k, 24k and Platinum

Scrap Sterling Silver Jewelry

Diamonds

Vintage and Estate Jewelry

Native American Silver Jewelry

Antique Pocket Watches and Quality Time Pieces

Sports Cards, Memorabilia, Collectibles and Supplies

National Distributor for TY Products

Coin Cases and Supplies

Baseball Card Supplies

Top Loader Card Protectors

Testimonials

Staff here is always friendly and polite. Have a good variety of items and hard to find things. Come in for silver and gold coins mainly but one of the few places in town to get baseball card hobby boxes and silver bullion.

- Steve Dalpia 01/01/2020

I've paid occasional visits for years, it's an eclectic and comfortable, laid-back business with lots of interesting coins and collectibles at unusually fair prices. They don't bother you while you're just looking around but are quick to assist when you see something of interest or want to chat a bit. They are quite knowledgeable and genuinely interested in finding the "right" coin for your needs. If they don't have a coin in the grade that fits one's collection they won't push something sub-par and will keep an eye open for what you need. I don't sell much as I can do that myself on eBay but have sold junk silver before and was quite pleased with their fair buy price. Their prices on supplies are great and I've actually found non-coin antiques at profitable bargain prices there so even deal-hunting resellers should check them out, it's a cool shop.

- Steve Lipov 12/24/2019

Good selection of coins, bullion, and collectibles. Helpful and friendly staff. AWESOME buy prices for bullion. Only reason I don't give them 5 stars is because their buy prices for coins are way below market.

- Joshua Whitley 09/08/2019

Friendly customer service a fun place to shop. Great deals. Honest helpful people run this business. Everything you could ask for in a collectibles shop. They buy and sell coins, also gold and silver at the best prices I have ever found. Don't miss out. You will be glad you stopped by.

- Marcy L. 06/26/2019

Great deals on coins, and the staff is always willing to sit down and give you their personal opinion. Friendly staff and great selections!

- Lane Sauder 06/08/2019

Started going there three years ago. Always helpful, great selection of silver, gold and coins. Will stop in again anytime we can.

- Keith Bittner 05/05/2019

Honest, patient, friendly

- Geneva Becker 03/12/2019

Great place, friendly

- Holly Dorsey 03/02/2019

Nice store nice people!

- Jerry Muss 02/03/2019

Decent selection of silver.

- William Holland 02/03/2019

The best place to visit to buy or sell gold or silver! Very nice staff wonderful people in general.

- J HUSTLE 01/04/2019

Great place. Very honest!

- Sandy F 11/05/2018

This place is amazing! Awesome selection and pricing is more than fair

- Scott Claudin 10/06/2018

Wendy is the nicest and most honest coin dealer you'll ever have the pleasure of doing business with. Just my opinion but when you need coins and supplies there is no one better than Wendy.

- David Noe 09/06/2018

Great place for a collector to get good deals on new pieces as well as top dollar for anything you're selling

- Jamie Thomas 08/07/2018

Staff are really helpful and friendly. They are also a member of the professional numismatists guild, and the only dealer with that certification for 100 miles. They're regulars at local shows. Great place!

- Katherine Birkel 06/08/2018

super nice people! convenience for sure always had a great experience! super nice people with a wealth of knowledge

- Jah Glastle 05/06/2018

Kind of a laid back group, not that's bad, just a little different than I am used to in business. Regardless, they did a good job of evaluating the valve of the items i brought them and paid a fare price for them.

- Don Kumpf 04/09/2018

I love this shop. They not only have a variety of collectable items, but every time I visit I feel like I'm walking into the Cheers of coin shops....

- Phillip Mott 03/29/2018

Wendy and Jerry are some the best and most honest business owners and dealers you can find. They are both very dedicated to their family the community asnd their customers. A real pleasure to conduct business with them on a regular basis.

- James Kellerstrass 03/05/2018

Sells a lot of silver coin of all kinds. Morgan's, Peace, Liberty and much more. They sell collectables, jewelry. This is a great shop just to stop in and look around. You're likely to find someone to take home.

- charlotte morris 03/05/2018

Always good service and fair prices - keeps me coming back.

- Dave Youngman 03/05/2018

This is one of those hidden gem shops.

- Clarence Carr 03/05/2018

Quick service

- Michelle Jahn 03/05/2018

Very informative

- Scott Rages 03/05/2018

Nice people, fair prices. Great place!

- Christopher Herrera 03/05/2018

Love Wendy's been going my whole life. Fair prices and wide variety of collectables. Would definitely recommend

- mikee menthol 03/05/2018

Wendy and Jerry are square Fair and upstanding extremely honest in the business best ever!

- mark collins 03/05/2018

Wendy's has a Great Selection and can satisfy my every numismatic need. They are Great People and always make me feel at home when I walk through the door.

- Danny Blevins 03/05/2018

Totally professional and trustworthy. Great place to buy and sell precious metals.

- Jason Puckett 03/05/2018

Always got the best price here for my bulk silver coins.

- rick farmer 03/05/2018

I have enjoyed going over to Wendy's collectibles for a few years now. They have a wide variety of collectibles that are completely top shelf. I have...

- Tim Larkin 12/02/2017

Experts in the business ! Very nice people , always helpful !

- Debbie Henderson 08/14/2017

Great service and friendly, knowledgeable staff! Best prices in town by far.

- Nathan Starr 03/05/2017

Honest place to trade in your good and silver and pick up a collectable while your there.

- Karen Buss 03/05/2017

Wendi and all the crew are really good people and very knowledgeable and fair!

- Trista Howell 03/05/2017

Good prices for silver

- Amanda Sellers 03/05/2017

Polite

- Jonna Mathiesen 03/05/2017

If you collect anything, this store may have it or can probably get what you're looking for. The prices weren't too bad. I wish I had more time to spend there

- Dan S. 02/24/2017

Hands down the best place! Can't wait to go back.

- Shawn Banks 01/18/2017

Love Wendy's. We have been shopping with her for years.

- Marsha Hiatt 12/23/2016

Very fair and amazing staff. Check here first. Don't go elsewhere!

- Bob Davis 03/15/2016

Was in the store on 11/21 and I thought it was a great little shop with the friendliest helpful staff.

- Brandon Donnelli 11/21/2015

Wendys is the best place around. They have great knowledge of the products they sell, prices are very competitive and they are very honest people....

- Jonathan Stenzel 01/03/2015

Great Shop... Great People... True Asset in the Peoria Market.. Thanks for all your hard work...

- Brandon Plattner 03/04/2014

Most Honest and friendly coin shop I have ever been too !!!!!!!!!

- Steven Henderson 10/25/2013